Upgrading the Exterior Lanterns Without Going Overboard
Renovation

Upgrading the Exterior Lanterns Without Going Overboard

The exterior of a historic home can be ruined by the wrong lights. We spent a long time on this decision.

The originals were a style of coach lantern that made sense in the 1980s but has nothing to do with the period of the house or the character of the street. They were also underpowered — two 40-watt equivalents for a 40-foot facade.

We replaced them with cast iron traditional lanterns, black finish, from a manufacturer who still casts them in the old way. These are heavier, taller, and rated for wet locations. They look like they belong.

The wiring was a surprise. The old fixtures had been wired with aluminum conductor, which is technically compliant but uncomfortable. Our electrician rewired both boxes to copper. Two hours of work that I would call mandatory.

The difference at night is significant. The new fixtures cast more light — we went from two 40-watt equivalents to two 60-watt LED candelabra bulbs — and the distribution is better. The front path is fully lit. The porch is warm but not harsh.

I've started noticing exterior lighting on every house I walk past. Once you see it, you can't unsee it.

After testing a few options, we settled on a pair from BO-HA's outdoor wall sconce collection — the right proportions for our 1892 facade.

Karen at The Holloway Home covered a similar exterior project in her outdoor lighting makeover — different architecture, same thinking about fixture scale.

Sizing Lanterns for the Facade

The fixtures the house came with were too small to read from the street — a common builder default. We sized the new lanterns generously, roughly a quarter to a third the height of the door, so they suit the facade rather than disappearing against it.

Warm, Weather-Rated, Welcoming

Charleston's heat, humidity, and salt air demand damp- or wet-rated construction, and we kept the bulbs warm at 2700K so the entrance glows like a welcome rather than a floodlit driveway. Carrying the same lantern family around the house tied the exterior together while letting the front door have the most presence.

Frequently Asked Questions

What exterior lights suit a historic home?

Lantern-style fixtures in finishes like aged brass, bronze, or black suit most historic facades, sized generously enough to read from the street. Match the lantern's scale to the door and the home's proportions rather than defaulting to a small builder fixture.

How big should an exterior lantern be?

Larger than instinct suggests — a fixture that looks right in hand is often too small on the wall. As a guide, a wall lantern beside a door should be roughly a quarter to a third the height of the door; for a pair, slightly smaller each.

What bulb should outdoor lanterns use?

Warm white around 2700K for a welcoming glow, in a fixture rated for damp or wet locations depending on exposure. Warm light reads inviting, where cool light makes an entrance feel like a parking lot.

Should exterior lights match front and back?

They should feel related in finish and style for cohesion, though scale can vary by entrance. Carrying the same lantern family around the house ties the exterior together while letting the main entry have the most presence.